This sentiment captures the human reality behind what can often feel like a purely procedural exercise. But how do the most experienced leaders approach these difficult conversations and what can we learn about how to handle redundancies with dignity and care?
The Reality Behind the Boardroom Door
Understanding how to handle redundancies starts with recognising the economic pressures that drive these decisions. As my CEO guest explained, “It is a sad inevitability that all businesses have economic cycles… and it is a reality that quite often the cost of people is the single biggest cost of a business.”
However, what separates values-driven leaders from others is their approach. The principle of being “hard on the problem and soft on the people” becomes crucial when handling redundancies effectively.
Behind closed doors, the best leaders don’t make these decisions in isolation. Instead, they empower their executive teams to create proposals, giving those who will implement and live with the decisions a real voice in shaping them. As the CEO explained, “the more you can give all aspects of this process power of determination from those that have gotta live with it, the more… there is some sense of followership and respect for the process.” This approach fosters genuine ownership rather than simply handing down directives from the boardroom.
Timing and Communication: The Foundation of Handling Redundancies Well
One of the most critical aspects of how to handle redundancies lies in timing your communications effectively. The key is involving not just senior executives but the next layer down – the managers who will be “fronting the majority of the conversations and living with the pain of those conversations.”
When these managers are brought into the process early, they develop ownership of the narrative. This means when they deliver difficult news, they can do so with authenticity rather than simply “doing our bidding.”
The Art of the Announcement
Perhaps counterintuitively, when it comes to announcing redundancies, shorter is better. As our CEO shared about the ideal length of the announcement: “The shortest one possible… as soon as people hear the word redundancy or change, the only thing that kicks into their mind is, what does that mean for me?”
People stop listening to lengthy explanations once they hear there will be job losses. Instead, the focus should be on clarity. Headline the changes upfront, then save the detailed narrative for individual conversations during the process.
The HR Partnership: Balancing Objectivity with Humanity
Successfully handling redundancies requires a delicate balance between legal compliance and human sensitivity. The HR function must maintain objectivity to ensure the process is legally sound, whilst line managers lead the empathetic conversations.
This doesn’t mean HR should be cold – quite the opposite. The best HR teams provide crucial support to line managers, offering “a safe place for them to vent off, to share their anxieties and to have a somewhat more human touch conversation behind closed doors.”
The Loneliness of Leadership
Leading through redundancies can be isolating. As our CEO reflected: “There is no lonelier role than CEO… you find yourself teetering on the edge of self-doubt around are we getting this right?”
The most effective leaders resist the urge to intervene directly, instead channelling their support through proper lines of management. The CPO or HRD becomes crucial here – serving as a confidential sounding board and helping craft the tone of the entire process.
Making It Memorable for the Right Reasons
One particularly powerful insight shared was about making redundancy “the most memorable departure that employees could ever encounter.” This might sound contradictory but when executed thoughtfully, it can transform how people remember their experience.
The proof? When this CEO’s business later reopened roles, a third of those who had been made redundant wanted to return – testament to how they were treated during their departure.
Practical Advice for Leaders at Every Level
When it comes to handling redundancies effectively, several key principles emerge:
- Be thorough in your planning. Avoid “death by a thousand cuts” – make decisions once, clearly and create certainty for those remaining. As volatile as business can be, aim for at least a year’s horizon before potentially revisiting workforce levels.
- Empower your managers. Give line managers the authority to deliver news in their own way within legal boundaries. People don’t leave businesses; they leave their bosses – so let those relationships carry the conversation.
- Stay true to your values. If there’s ever a time for company values to show up, it’s during the toughest times, not the easiest ones. This is when you discover whether your values are real or just wall decorations.
- Don’t avoid the emotional reality. Senior leaders who try to isolate themselves from the pain of the process often transmit that detachment throughout the organisation. Authenticity matters – people can sense when leadership truly cares.
Bottom Line When Handling Redundancies? The Human Element Cannot Be Forgotten
Ultimately, successfully handling redundancies comes down to never losing sight of the human impact. It’s about families, futures and livelihoods. The most effective leaders remember that whilst redundancy may be a business necessity, how it’s conducted is always a choice.
As our CEO concluded: “There’s no way of dressing it up… the more it can be empathetic, authentic, owned and with as much humanity as possible in it, it’s as good as you’re ever gonna make it.”
That’s the standard worth striving for in every redundancy process.
Discover more content like this in our Redundancy Matters podcast, or wherever you listen to your podcasts.
If you’d like to keep in touch to receive regular content on Redundancy, Outplacement, and to be notified when our podcast episodes land you can join our mailing list.
And if you want to find out more about our services you can get in touch to discuss how we could support you with our Outplacement Support Services.